Author Archives: angelo@percorso.net

Evolutionary diversity in the Amazon

Amazon forests with the greatest evolutionary diversity are the most productive, an international team of researchers led by the University of Leeds have revealed.

The team used long term records from 90 plots as part of the Amazon Forest Inventory Network (RAINFOR) and ForestPlots.net to track the lives and productivity of individual trees across the Amazon region.

By combining these records with DNA sequence data – which identified the evolutionary relationships among all the species – the team was able to investigate the links between how fast different forests grow and their diversity.

Biodiverse ecosystems

Their study demonstrated that the plots with the greatest evolutionary diversity were a third more productive compared to areas with the least evolutionary diversity.

The finding suggest that evolutionary diversity should be an important consideration when identifying priority areas for conservation.

Study lead author Fernanda Coelho from the School of Geography at Leeds said: “Understanding how biodiversity affects productivity in tropical forests is important because it allows us to understand how conservation strategies can best be designed to maximise protection of species and the services that these ecosystems provide.

“Our results indicate that we should include evolutionary history in conservation priorities – because ecosystem function may be higher in areas where species come from right across the tree of life.”

This Article

This article is based on a press release from the University of Leeds.

Image: Fernanda Coelho, University of Leeds.

Labour takes aim at hare coursing and fox hunting

Labour will tomorrow announce additional police resources to support plans laid out in the most radical animal welfare plan anywhere in the world.

The plans will double the number of police officers tasked to prosecute wildlife crimes from the current 88 to 170, increasing the capability of rural crime units to prosecute wildlife crime. The new wildlife crime officers will not reduce allocations to frontline policing.

Wildlife offences include hare coursing, which has emerged as a significant problem across farmlands, and acts outlawed by Labour’s 2004 Hunting Act, like fox hunting and stag hunting.

Crimes

Sue Hayman, Labour’s shadow environment secretary, said: “Labour’s animal welfare manifesto is the most radical animal welfare plan anywhere in the world.

“While the Tories continue with their mass slaughter of badgers and flip flop on bringing back fox hunting, Labour is determined to bring animal welfare policy into the 21st Century, based on the latest science and understanding.

“We are calling time on those who have been allowed to get away with illegally hunting, maiming and killing wild animals such as deer, hen harriers, foxes and hares.

“By increasing the number of wildlife and rural police forces across the country we will help protect both wild animals and property in rural communities, and ensure a crackdown on the types of crimes against animals that this Tory government has turned a blind eye to.

Strict

“Labour is the true party of real change when it comes to animal welfare.”

Other wildlife crime offences include badger and raptor baiting. Prosecutions in England and Wales for crimes like baiting, poaching and hunting have plummeted by a third since 2016.

Working in partnership with regional organised crime units, the additional officers will also act as the eyes and ears of other crimes including animal welfare crimes taking place in rural areas, like livestock theft and dog fighting, which are often linked to serious organised crime.

Labour’s commitment to increase wildlife crime policing will enable more effective actions against existing crime and will ensure police forces are ready to enforce planned new offences and stricter rules.

Loopholes

Labour’s animal welfare manifesto includes additional plans to:

·        Close loopholes in the 2004 Hunting Act that allow in practice the continuation of illegal hunting of foxes, deer and hares.

·        Introduce a ‘recklessness’ clause to the Act, to prevent trail hunts being used as cover for the illegal hunting of wild mammals.

·        Remove the exemption for ‘research and observation’ hunting.

·        Remove the exemption for ‘use of dogs below ground to protect birds for shooting’.

·        Review the penalties available under the Hunting Act 2004.

·        Consult on the introduction of custodial sentences for illegal hunting, bringing it in line with the penalties for other wildlife crimes.

This Author

Brendan Montague is editor of The Ecologist. This story is based on a press release from The Labour Party.

Labour promises 886,000 climate apprenticeships

Labour has promised to create a climate apprenticeship programme which will train an average of 80,000 people a year.

The party said it will also bring in reforms to the apprenticeship levy in a bid to better meet the needs of workers and employers, as well as tackling the climate emergency.

Under the plans, Labour said they will deliver 320,000 apprenticeships in England during their first term in government, with the programme creating 886,000 by 2030.

Levy

Climate apprenticeships will “upskill” the UK workforce so that UK companies can compete and succeed in the green economy, the party said.

Under the plans, businesses will benefit from an average of 80,000 people per year being trained as apprentice engineers and technicians in renewable energy and transport, civil engineers and skilled tradespeople in sustainable construction, designers, welders and fabricators in low carbon industries, and sustainable agriculture and forestry specialists.

Labour said the programme will be funded by diverting 25% of the funds employers already set aside through the Apprenticeship Levy and topped up by any dividends over the cap paid into Labour’s Inclusive Ownership Funds, which the party said is expected to be £700 million by 2024.

Labour said they will give employers more flexibility in how they spend their levy funds, and among reforms are allowing levy funds to be redeemed for a wider range of accredited training and extending the period of time allowed for employers to spend their levy.

Emergency

The party said it will also increase the amount of money businesses are allowed to transfer to non-levy paying small and medium-sized businesses.

Speaking to business leaders at the Confederation of British Industry annual conference on Monday, Leader Jeremy Corbyn is expected to say: “Labour’s Green Industrial Revolution will be a central motor of the party’s plans to transform our country and economy, using public investment to create good, clean jobs, tackle the climate emergency and rebuild held back towns, cities and communities.

“Climate Apprenticeships will offer training to school leavers and workers looking to change jobs mid-career, creating the engineers, technicians and construction workers we need to transition to a green economy.

“This election is our last chance to tackle the climate emergency. The Tories have failed to invest in our economy, failed to deliver apprenticeships and failed to face up to the climate emergency.”

This Author

Catherine Wylie is a reporter with PA.

Insights into the Serengeti ecosystem

American ethologist Richard Despard Estes is a world authority on the wildebeest (gnu) and their epic migration through the Serengeti national park in Tanzania (including the Ngorongoro Conservation Area, the gateway to the Serengeti), an extension of the Masai Mara ecosystem in neighbouring Kenya.

Estes, now age 91, received his doctorate in vertebrate zoology from Cornell University following undergraduate studies at Harvard, and began his pioneering field study of this prolific antelope in October 1962 when he became the first foreigner to live on the floor of Ngorongoro Crater in over a generation.

In his 1958 land rover pickup, often in the company of his Austrian-born wife Runi, whom he met and married in Tanzania and who later assisted his research by translating German literature dealing with animal behaviur, Estes traversed the open plains, montane grasslands and lush forests making discoveries over the course of half a century of not only of the wildebeest but insights into the interconnectedness of other wild species of fauna and flora in the Serengeti ecosystem including in the soil itself.

What first attracted you to the wildebeest given the fact that you have also studied other African antelope’s?

Wildebeest were the most numerous and, I suspected, the most ecologically important of the antelopes. 

What has been your greatest discovery studying the wildebeest and its migration on the Serengeti?

The territorial behaviour of the males, which I first observed in Ngorongoro Crater. Why, I wondered, would these individuals, members of a species whose habit of gathering in dense concentrations proved they were highly sociable, isolate themselves like this? Could they be defending territories?

Oddly enough, the first behavioural observation I made as i gazed into the void of Ngorongoro Crater became the subject of my doctoral dissertation-the territorial behaviour of wildebeest.  

How do wildebeests drive the ecology and evolution of the Serengeti – the largest eoc-system in the world?

The migrating wildebeests create and maintain the Serengeti ecosystem. They churn the soil with their hooves and nourish it with their urine and dung.  

Males bashing bushes with their horns in territorial displays help keep the savanna from growing into forest. Even a component in the wildebeests’ saliva has been found to stimulate grass to grow.  And because the animals move on after grazing, (unlike cattle) the grasses grow back, stronger than ever. 

We already know what the predators and scavengers get out of the serengeti migration-lunch, but what do the hundreds of thousands of zebras, gazelles and other antelopes get out of it?

I counted twenty-eight other species of mammals that can thrive in Serengeti because of the wildebeest migration. But new studies suggest that number may be too low.

Additional species that benefit range from aquatic micro-organisms and fish (nourished by the carcasses of gnus who die crossing rivers) to giraffes (whose babies suffer less from predation when the wildebeest migration sweeps through their territories. wildebeest are even more important to the ecosystem than I could have imagined when i began my work in 1962. 

At age ten, in the midst of the American museum of natural history in MYC, you made up your mind to go to Africa.

I was fascinated with the diversity of animals there and wanted to learn more about them. I did not know then that I could make a career studying african animals. 

What kind of family did you have and were they supportive about your passion for African wildlife and to live there?

My father was a lawyer; my mother a homemaker; I had an older brother. There was no support from my parents because my mother died when i was 11. My father died when i was 14. 

Who were some of your well-known contemporaries at Harvard, where you studied sociology and social anthropology?

George Plimpton and Henry Kissinger were fellow 1950 grads of Harvard. More important to me, en route to my work in Burma, I would meet Nobel Laureates Niko Tinbergen and Konrad Lorenz, who along with Carl von Frisch were the founders of ethology-the study of animal behaviour.

They were not associated with Harvard but I had the opportunity to spend a summer at the Max Planck Institute for Behavioural Physiology in Bavaria and studied with Lorenz, and met other influential biologists including Ernst Mayr and von Frisch.

In 1958, you travelled to Burma [Myanmar] to conduct a wildlife survey. What was that experience like. 

The field experience was very helpful, though the animals were quite different. However, the great diversity of animals there fascinated me.

Do you recall any adventures in Burma?

One day I was sitting at a waterhole and sensed that a tiger was circling me. I still have the teapot from a different person’s neighbouring camp that was upended by a tiger who jumped over a log, picked up a person in its mouth, and ran into the forest with him. 

have you ever gotten caught up in some political chaos or natural disaster during your field studies in Africa or Asia?

Thankfully, no. In 78-81 we ran into food shortages in Tanzania because of the war with Uganda, but the country itself was calm.

Your two African wildlife books: The Behavior Guide to African Mammals and The Safari Companion are classics. Are they still as popular as they once were? 

The two books are currently being used to train safari guides throughout Africa. As of 2018, the Behaviour Guide has sold 30,000+ copies, and the Safari Companion sold 52,200+ copies.

How did the idea of the rare species conservatory foundation come about and what have been some of its accomplishments ?

Paul Reillo founded it. He has been protecting rare species of all sorts, especially birds, I was a founding board member. Our daughter Anna and son Lyndon are associates, too. It’s dedicated to preserving global biodiversity.  

Why was there a decline in Kenya’s bongo population to the point where you had to help repatriate American-bred bongos to Kenya? What time period was this?

The Bongo antelope was another victim of habitat destruction and poaching. The bongo SSP was founded in 1999.

The rare species conservatory is essential for reporting what is happening in the field among all antelopes during a period when many species were facing endangerment and which I chaired and co-chaired for almost three decades, contributed bongo to the Jacksonville zoo-one of the 47 zoos that supplied bongo for repatriation to the Mount Kenya Game Ranch in 2004. 

What are some of the greatest threats to the Serengeti ecosystem and how are humans involved?

Foreign plants are taking hold where native grasses once flourished. Poachers snare 100,000 wildebeest a year in Serengeti alone. Herders’ animals compete with native animals for graze; climate change skews rainfall; tourists’ vehicles compact soil and carve ruts into grasses, and every year, as Africa’s population is projected to double in the next 20 years, more houses, roads, fences, and farms crowd the land the animals need to survive.   

What are some of the environmental and social blowbacks that humans will feel if we lose the wildebeest migration to the rising bushmeat trade, capitalist market forces and socio-economic development?  

As for the human social consequences, when an entire ecosystem collapses, humans – who grew up in this ecosystem – will profoundly feel the loss.

I could also cite the considerable money lost to the Kenyan and Tanzanian tourist industry (extremely important to both countries’ economies) but as Sy Montgomery writes in her recent book: “If we lose (the migration), we deserve no second change. We forfeit forever the spectacle and renewal of the world’s most magnificent migration.”      

This Author

Curtis Abraham is a freelance writer and researcher on African development, science, the environment, biomedical/health and African social/cultural history. He has lived and worked in sub-Saharan Africa for over two decades with his work appearing in numerous publications including New ScientistBBC Wildlife MagazineNew African and Africa Geographic.

Ditch the cages

Compassion in World Farming, a leading farm animal welfare charity, is urging the UK’s three largest bargain retailers – Poundland, B&M, and Home Bargains – to commit to a cage free future for hens.

Since 2015, there has been a huge wave of food businesses across the globe pledging to go cage free. All the UK’s major supermarket chains have either stopped selling eggs from caged hens or have pledged to go cage free by 2025 and many popular restaurant chains, including Frankie & Bennie’s, Café Rouge and Pizza Express, have also made cage free commitments.  

Compassion is now calling on Poundland, B&M, and Home Bargains to join the cage free revolution.

Hens

Around sixteen million laying hens in the UK are currently kept in cages. These animals will spend almost their entire lives confined, with barely enough room to spread their wings.

Animal welfare is a significant concern for UK shoppers, with 81% of the public believing cages in farming are cruel and over two-thirds (67 percent) feeling that this method of farming is outdated.

At a time when the market is shifting towards higher animal welfare standards, it’s deeply disappointing that Poundland, B&M and Home Bargains still sell eggs from caged hens.

Misery

Compassion has written to the retailers on multiple occasions over recent months, but they have failed to make a cage free commitment.

Natasha Smith, UK Campaigns Manager at Compassion in World Farming, said: “These so called ‘cheap’ eggs may seem like a good deal, but they come at a high price to the millions of hens confined in cages.

“We must ensure there is no market for caged eggs anywhere in Britain. Major UK food businesses have already committed to a cage-free future – it’s high time for bargain retailers to follow suit.”  

“Caged eggs on any store shelf will mean millions of hens may continue to live a life of misery, year after year.”

This Article

This article is based on a press release from Compassion in World Farming.

Become a wildlife guardian

Fiery colours sweeping through parks and woodlands, complete with leaves crunching underfoot, mean autumn is here. But the colder nights and bitter winds mean garden birds will struggle for food and shelter. The RSPB is appealing to people to help our garden birds survive the winter.

Nature looks beautiful in autumn as summer leaves fade to a sunset palette of gold, red and orange. But as we start digging out our cosy scarves and gloves the countryside is being stripped of the food sources birds rely upon. At the same time, birds need more energy to stay warm and have less daylight time to find food.

Wildlife charity RSPB wants people to become stewards of their gardens this autumn and help protect their feathered guests. The RSPB says the key things birds will need this winter are food, water and shelter.

Real difference 

RSPB Wildlife Advisor, Charlotte Ambrose said: “Up until now birds have been able to feed on insects and seeds, but the cold weather means they move into our gardens to find refuge.

“You can make a real difference and improve their chances of survival, as well as being rewarded by great views of wildlife in your garden or outside space.”

Take it easy – kitchen scraps like mild grated cheese, bruised fruit (not mouldy), cooked rice, unsalted bits of hard fat, roast potatoes and dry porridge go down a treat with garden birds. You can provide an excellent full-fat winter food by making your own bird cakes or fat balls. The RSPB also suggests calorie-rich foods like mixed seed, sunflower seed, nyjer seed and good quality peanuts.

No thank you! There are some foods you should avoid as they can be dangerous for birds. Cooking fat from the roast mixes with meat juices during cooking to make a runny, greasy mixture. This sticks to feathers and stop them from being waterproof. Other foods to avoid are dried coconut, cooked porridge oats, milk, and mouldy or salted food.

Keep it fresh: Another essential is fresh water for drinking and bathing. Finding sources of water can be hard with freezing temperatures, but a simple trick will help keep a patch of water ice-free. Float a small ball, such as a ping-pong ball, on the surface of the water and even a light breeze will stop it from freezing over.

Plan your planting: Providing shelter from the harsh weather is extremely important. Plant dense hedges such as privet or hawthorn, or let ivy or holly to grow and you’ll be providing a great place to roost in and shelter from the elements.

Warm and cozy: Nestboxes are not just used over the summer egg-laying season – many birds will use them on a cold winter’s night. These boxes are frequently communal with many residents packing in together for extra warmth. The record number of birds found in one box is 63 wrens!

Sign up 

Ensuring your garden is filled with food now will improve your chances of having a successful Big Garden Birdwatch.

The RSPB’s annual event runs from Saturday 25 to Monday 27 January 2020. To take part, all you need to do is spend one hour at any time over that weekend noting the number of feathered visitors to your garden or local green space. You can sign up for this year’s Big Garden Birdwatch from 12 December. 

This Article

This article is based on a press release from the RSPB. 

Climate change impacts on food production

Each year, the earth’s population grows, impacting the environment in small, subtle ways that add up over time. Unfortunately, climate change affects every aspect of our lives, right down to the ways we produce our food and how efficient our agriculture systems are.

One study conducted by Arizona State University found greenhouse gas emissions could cause the yield of vegetables to fall by 35% by 2100. The reasons for the lower yields varied between factors such as water shortages and an increase in salinity and less filtering of the sun’s rays. 

To adapt to a changing climate, farmers will have to change the way they produce food, and there may even be concerns with growing enough food to keep up with supply.

Weather concerns

As the ozone layer becomes further eroded, crops will suffer from long, hot days. In traditionally milder climates, the types of vegetables grown may change to adapt to shifting weather.

Some crops are better able to withstand harsher sunlight than others, so rather than growing sensitive plants such as lettuces, farmers might shift to root crops such as turnips or carrots. The selection of fruits and vegetables may become smaller as a result.

It’s more likely the agriculture industry will turn to hothouses or hydroponic growing methods to produce plants. However, if water shortages are an issue, hydroponic crops may become a thing of the past. Farmers may look for chemical solutions to grow food in, which would, in turn, impact the food itself by adding chemicals that don’t naturally occur.

Global warming could result in shifting weather patterns, as well. Natural disasters can further impact agriculture and the meat industry, reducing the available food and driving up prices. Farmers must have a clear plan for how to deal with an approaching storm and its aftermath.

Winters could become harsher, summers hotter and the milder weather of fall and spring would be a thing of the past. Consumers and farmers would have to adapt to changing seasons.

Wildfire devastation

You’ve likely heard about the California wildfires ravaging parts of the western United States. One aspect many people don’t consider is the overall impact and loss of life, as well as the loss of crops.

About 90% of the wildfires that occur are due to human error. People leave campfires unattended or flick a cigarette out their window while driving. Whatever the cause, once a spark hits the dry ground, the fire starts to rage almost uncontrollably.

An out-of-control fire damages grazing land, impacting farmers who raise livestock. It can also destroy crops, burn down buildings farmers need to store food and equipment and drive people out of their family farmland for good.

Extreme weather where it doesn’t rain for months on end causes the dried-out land that explodes into a blazing inferno. However, crops are also often rainfed, so when it doesn’t rain, a lack of moisture affects crops. Even if the fire doesn’t reach the farmland, the food may become unusable as plants wither and die. 

On the other end of the extreme, when it finally does rain, the parched land may not be able to soak in all the water at once, and flooding occurs. Floods can cause issues such as storm drains and sewage overflowing and running into food supplies.

Increased production

Agricultural specialists work hard to produce stronger, more disease-resistant and higher-yield crops. Unfortunately, with the science comes some concerns over genetically modified foods and what they might do to the human body over time. Climate change has already impacted our food supply, and time will tell how much it is for the better or worse.

A rise in carbon dioxide in our climate could increase some crops such as rice, soybean and wheat. These types of food are not as high in nutrients and cancer-fighting agents as green leafy vegetables, for example. 

Flooding, changing seasons and other weather changes impact the growing seasons of specific crops and could cause more and more damage to outdoor crops, driving some food production indoors and spiking prices at the same time. Farmers will have to shift what they grow and how they grow it to keep up with an expanding population.

There is some good news for farmers in the northern United States, Canada and Russia, though. One report predicted the conditions in those areas would improve for producing food. However, conditions in portions of Australia and in the Mediterranean will deteriorate.

Global climate change will force scientists to figure out how to produce more, waste less and grow food even in less-than-ideal conditions. While many negatives accompany climate change, learning to better use the resources we have as inhabitants of our green planet is a positive move in the right direction.

Changing things

While some people believe the earth is past the tipping point where we have a chance to reverse the damage done to our climate, others believe it isn’t too late to teach upcoming generations to care for the environment.

Small changes, such as conserving water, growing your food and reducing your carbon footprint, may start to shift things so food shortages and water scarcity aren’t as much of a concern in the next 50 years.

This Author 

Emily Folk is a regular contributor to The Ecologist, a conservation and sustainability writer and the editor of Conservation Folks.

Hedge your bets and plant a natural screen

Gardeners should consider swapping walls and fences for hedges, says the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS), as new research shows how they provide a range of frontline environmental services.

The call forms part of the charity’s Greening Great Britain campaign which urges the public to turn urban concrete corners into thriving green spaces.

Analysis by the charity of 44 of the most popular hedges, found that as well as mitigating flooding, capturing pollutants and acting as a sound barrier they can also be used to help heat and cool the home. Hedge species in urban environments were also found to provide a crucial resource for a wide diversity of animal species through the provision of shelter, nest sites, food resources and corridors for movement.

Urban hedges

The best all-round performers suitable for UK gardens include beech, holly, privet, western red cedar and rose.

The varying structure of hedges makes them well suited for specific roles. Those with hairy, rough and oval leaves, were found to better capture and retain particulates with dense, but porous canopies capturing the most.

A yew canopy exposed to roadside pollution can accumulate and retain, for example, four times more particles than Photinia which has smoother leaves and is less dense. 

Meanwhile wide, tall and layered evergreen species have been shown to act as sound barriers with English yew (Taxus baccata) and western red cedar (Thuja plicata) found to be the top performing.

Tijana Blanusa, Principal Horticultural Scientist, at the RHS said: “In a world that is rapidly urbanising and where there is pressure on land use through the increased densification of cities, the relatively compact nature of the urban hedge may have a pivotal role in ensuring our cities remain ‘liveable’, through its various ecosystem benefits.”

This Article 

This article is based on a press release from RHS. 

‘A policy from a parallel universe’

Environmental lawyers ClientEarth have criticised a leak of Germany’s draft coal phase-out law as put together by the Ministry for Economic Affairs, calling it out of touch and piecemeal, and lambasting the failure to tie it to climate protection goals.

Prof. Dr. Hermann Ott, Head of ClientEarth – Anwälte der Erde, said: “The long-awaited draft of Germany’s phase-out law is a shambles. The policy is riddled with unanswered questions, guarantees an unacceptably tardy coal exit and fails completely to acknowledge how urgently we need to decarbonise to address climate change.

“Those writing the policy seem to be existing in a parallel universe where coal is still profitable, people aren’t being forced out of their homes for mining, and the climate catastrophe isn’t unfolding around us.”

‘Incoherent policymaking’

Ott continued: “We are still faced with the total failure to tackle the phase-out of lignite, the most polluting form of coal, suggesting that Germany is still in thrall to vast energy companies which are still expanding mines and committing major rights infringements.

“And far from a logical approach to securing energy as coal is phased out, we’re actually seeing obstacles to renewable energy growth, which puts the entire phase-out at risk.

“Germany is one of Europe’s leading economies, and it is embarrassing to see such totally incoherent policymaking at a time we’ve never needed strong, solid climate action more.”

Key issues 

The main reason Germany’s ‘Coal Commission’ was formed was to decide how to manage a coal phase-out to cut carbon emissions in order to protect the climate. But this rationale is not made explicit in the law as it stands – and without climate protection as a guiding principle, the law is much less likely to perform against its intended objectives.

The leaked law contains provisions on how to phase out the first Gigawatts (GW) of hard coal to 2026 via tender procedures. If these do not reach the intended GW reduction, no possibility of state-enforced closures is planned in the law, which puts the phase-out path at risk entirely.

The law leaves the GW-reduction path for hard coal for the period from 2027 to 2038 (or earlier) to be determined by a future government by 2022. The already late end date of 2038 will only be assessed for the first time in 2032; earlier assessments by an expert committee, according to the draft, would only result in recommendations to the government and no commitments.

The draft law still needs to pass the cabinet next Monday and only then will pass on to the parliament, but presumably not before the end of this year. The law also does not yet contain any details on how the phase-out of lignite in Germany will take place, which is extremely bad news for those in Germany who stand to lose their villages for coal mining.

The leaked draft of the coal phase-out law contains changes to many other laws, too, among them a provision in construction law that in the future would limit the expansion of wind energy considerably.

This Author

Brendan Montague is editor of The Ecologist. This article is based on a press release from ClientEarth. 

‘A policy from a parallel universe’

Environmental lawyers ClientEarth have criticised a leak of Germany’s draft coal phase-out law as put together by the Ministry for Economic Affairs, calling it out of touch and piecemeal, and lambasting the failure to tie it to climate protection goals.

Prof. Dr. Hermann Ott, Head of ClientEarth – Anwälte der Erde, said: “The long-awaited draft of Germany’s phase-out law is a shambles. The policy is riddled with unanswered questions, guarantees an unacceptably tardy coal exit and fails completely to acknowledge how urgently we need to decarbonise to address climate change.

“Those writing the policy seem to be existing in a parallel universe where coal is still profitable, people aren’t being forced out of their homes for mining, and the climate catastrophe isn’t unfolding around us.”

‘Incoherent policymaking’

Ott continued: “We are still faced with the total failure to tackle the phase-out of lignite, the most polluting form of coal, suggesting that Germany is still in thrall to vast energy companies which are still expanding mines and committing major rights infringements.

“And far from a logical approach to securing energy as coal is phased out, we’re actually seeing obstacles to renewable energy growth, which puts the entire phase-out at risk.

“Germany is one of Europe’s leading economies, and it is embarrassing to see such totally incoherent policymaking at a time we’ve never needed strong, solid climate action more.”

Key issues 

The main reason Germany’s ‘Coal Commission’ was formed was to decide how to manage a coal phase-out to cut carbon emissions in order to protect the climate. But this rationale is not made explicit in the law as it stands – and without climate protection as a guiding principle, the law is much less likely to perform against its intended objectives.

The leaked law contains provisions on how to phase out the first Gigawatts (GW) of hard coal to 2026 via tender procedures. If these do not reach the intended GW reduction, no possibility of state-enforced closures is planned in the law, which puts the phase-out path at risk entirely.

The law leaves the GW-reduction path for hard coal for the period from 2027 to 2038 (or earlier) to be determined by a future government by 2022. The already late end date of 2038 will only be assessed for the first time in 2032; earlier assessments by an expert committee, according to the draft, would only result in recommendations to the government and no commitments.

The draft law still needs to pass the cabinet next Monday and only then will pass on to the parliament, but presumably not before the end of this year. The law also does not yet contain any details on how the phase-out of lignite in Germany will take place, which is extremely bad news for those in Germany who stand to lose their villages for coal mining.

The leaked draft of the coal phase-out law contains changes to many other laws, too, among them a provision in construction law that in the future would limit the expansion of wind energy considerably.

This Author

Brendan Montague is editor of The Ecologist. This article is based on a press release from ClientEarth.